September 18, 2012
Letter Stating that Student Loan is “Ineligible for Bankruptcy Discharge” is False, Deceptive and Misleading Statement under FDCPA
Student loans are presumptively nondischargeable in bankruptcy. However, student loans can be discharged in bankruptcy if a debtor demonstrates, by a preponderance of the evidence, that requiring their repayment would impose an undue hardship on the debtor. To seek an undue hardship discharge of student loans, a debtor must commence an adversary proceeding by serving a summons and complaint on affected creditors. To succeed in such a proceeding, the debtor must show: (1) that the debtor cannot maintain, based on current income and expenses, a ”minimal” standard of living for herself and her dependents if forced to repay the loans; (2) that additional circumstances exist indicating that this state of affairs is likely to persist for a significant portion of the repayment period of the student loans; and (3) that the debtor has made good faith efforts to repay the loans.
With this state of the law as a background, would a statement to a consumer that her/his student loan was “ineligible for discharge in bankruptcy” be deemed a false statement under the FDCPA? The Second Circuit recently responded to this question in the affirmative.
In Easterling v. Collecto, Inc., 2012 U.S. App. LEXIS 18444 (2d Cir. N.Y. Aug. 30, 2012), Berlincia Easterling obtained a student loan. Approximately 4 years later she filed for bankruptcy, however, in her petition, she classified the student loan as non-dischargeable. Accordingly, her student loan was not discharged. When the debt collector for the Department of Education learned about the bankruptcy, it sent Easterling a letter advising her that her account was “NOT eligible for bankruptcy discharge. After receiving the letter, Easterling filed a claim under the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (“FDCPA”), contending that the collection letter’s statement that her student loan was “ineligible for bankruptcy discharge” was false, deceptive, or misleading under the least sophisticated consumer standard. The District Court granted defendant/debt collector’s motion for summary judgment. Easterling appealed.
The Second Circuit held that the debt collector violated the FDCPA’s proscription against false, misleading, or deceptive practices by sending the debtor a collection letter incorrectly informing her that her student loans were “ineligible for bankruptcy discharge” because, although the debtor may have faced significant hurdles to discharging her student loans in bankruptcy, the least sophisticated consumer would have interpreted the letter as representing, incorrectly, that bankruptcy discharge of her loans was wholly unavailable to her. The appellate Court concluded that the letter’s capacity to discourage debtors from fully availing themselves of their legal rights rendered its misrepresentation exactly the kind of abusive debt collection practice that the FDCPA was designed to target.
The above statements do not represent those of Weston Legal or Michael Weston and they have not been reviewed for accuracy. The statements have been published by a third party and are being linked to by our website only because they contain information relating to debt. Nothing in this article should be construed as legal advice given by Weston Legal or Michael Weston. To view the source of the article, please following the link to the website that published the article. Articles written by Michael W. Weston can be viewed here: To report any problem with this article please email studentloan@westonlegal.com
Weston Legal provides Student Loan Lawsuit Defense in all cities of Texas including:
- Abilene
- Addison
- Alamo
- Aldine
- Alice
- Allen
- Alvin
- Amarillo
- Angleton
- Arlington
- Atascocita
- Austin
- Balch Springs
- Bay City
- BayTown
- Bedford
- Beaumont
- Bellaire
- Belton
- Benbrook
- Big Spring
- Brownsville
- Brownwood
- Brushy Creek
- Bryan
- Burleson
- Canyon Lake
- Carrollton
- Cedar Hill
- Cedar Park
- Channelview
- Cibolo
- Cinco Ranch
- Cleburne
- Cloverleaf
- College Station
- Colleyville
- Conroe
- Converse
- Coppel
- Copperas Cove
- Corinth
- Corsicana
- Dallas
- Deer Park
- Del Rio
- Denison
- Denton
- Desoto
- Dickinson
- Donna
- Duncanville
- Eagle Pass
- Edinburg
- El Paso
- Ennis
- Euless
- Farmers Branch
- Flower Mound
- Forney
- Fort Hood
- Friendswood
- Fresno
- Frisco
- Gainsville
- Garland
- Galveston
- Gatesville
- Georgetown
- Grand Prairie
- Grapevine
- Greenville
- Groves
- Haltom
- Harker Heights
- Harlingen
- Hereford
- Highland Village
- Horizon City
- Houston
- Humble
- Huntsville
- Hurst
- Irving
- Jollyville
- Keller
- Kileen
- Kingsville
- Kyle
- Lake Jackson
- Lancaster
- La Porte
- Laredo
- League City
- Leander
- Lewisville
- Little Elm
- Longview
- Lubbock
- Lufkin
- Mansfieled
- Marshal
- Mcallen
- Mckinney
- Mercedes
- Mesquite
- Midland
- Midlothian
- Mineral Wells
- Mission
- Missouri City
- Mount Pleasant
- Murphy
- Nacodoches
- Nederland
- New Braunfels
- New Territory
- North Richland Hills
- Odessa
- Orange
- Palestine
- Pampa
- Paris
- Pasedena
- Pearland
- Pecan Grove
- Pflugerville
- Pharr
- Plainview
- Plano
- Port Arthur
- Portland
- Richardson
- Rockwall
- Rosenberg
- Round Rock
- Rowlett
- Sachse
- Saginaw
- San Angelo
- San Antonio
- San Benito
- San Juan
- San Marcos
- Schertz
- Seguin
- Sherman
- Socorro
- South Houston
- South Lake
- Spring
- Stafford
- Stephenville
- Sugar Land
- Sulphur Springs
- Taylor
- Temple
- Terrel
- Texarkana
- Texas City
- The Colony
- The Woodlands
- Tyler
- Universal City
- Universal Park
- Uvalde
- Victoria
- Waco
- Watuga
- Waxahachie
- Weatherford
- Weslaco
- West Odessa
- West University
- White Settlement
- Wichita Falls
- Wylie